Anita Szigeti

The appellant, who was found not criminally responsible for second degree murder and assault with a weapon, appealed a disposition of the Ontario Review Board.

The Board had upheld restrictions on his liberty and imposed a hybrid disposition, finding he remained a significant threat to public safety due to aggressive behaviour and non-compliance with medication.

The appellant sought an absolute discharge under s. 672.54(a) of the Criminal Code.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding no basis to interfere with the Board's conclusion that the appellant remained a significant risk to public safety and that the hybrid disposition was the least restrictive and appropriate in the circumstances.

The appellant, previously found not criminally responsible for second-degree murder, appealed a disposition of the Ontario Review Board refusing an absolute discharge and continuing a conditional discharge.

The Board concluded the appellant continued to pose a significant threat to public safety due to a high likelihood of non-compliance with anti-psychotic medication if discharged absolutely.

The Court of Appeal found that the Board's decision was reasonable and supported by the evidence, particularly the expert opinion of a consulting forensic psychiatrist regarding the appellant's fluctuating insight into his condition.

The appeal was dismissed.

The appellant appealed a disposition of the Ontario Review Board, arguing the Board erred in concluding he continues to pose a significant threat to the safety of the public.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding the Board's decision was reasonable based on all the circumstances.

The appellant appealed a decision upholding a finding of incapacity to consent to treatment with antipsychotic medication.

The Court of Appeal found that the Consent and Capacity Board's decision was unreasonable because there was no evidence that the proposed treatment would benefit the appellant, nor any evidence of the consequences of refusing treatment.

The appeal was allowed and the finding of incapacity was set aside.