The complainant, who alleged reprisal after being permanently screened out of the police constable hiring process, brought a motion for the production of numerous documents and records from the respondents.
The Tribunal applied the 'arguable relevance' threshold for production in human rights proceedings.
The Tribunal ordered the production of certain uniform officers' notebook records from 2003-2004, but denied the remaining requests, finding them either irrelevant, overly broad, speculative, or already publicly available.