Roger Townshend

This costs endorsement addresses the entitlement of the Chippewas of Nawash Unceded First Nation and Saugeen First Nation (SON) to costs from Ontario following a partially successful appeal.

SON had sued Canada and Ontario for Aboriginal title to submerged lands and for breaches of fiduciary duty.

The Court of Appeal allowed SON’s title claim appeal to the extent of remitting the matter back to the trial judge for a determination on a more limited portion of the claim area, while dismissing their treaty claim appeal.

SON had settled costs with Canada and was not seeking costs for the treaty claim.

The court found that SON was the overall successful party on the title claim appeal against Ontario, as they obtained the relief sought (remittal), and Ontario's position was to dismiss the claim entirely.

The quantum of costs sought by SON was deemed reasonable given the complexity and public importance of the appeal.

This decision addresses a motion for intervener status in an appeal concerning novel issues of Aboriginal title to submerged lands and the public right of navigation.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario granted intervener status to four Indigenous communities, finding they could make a useful contribution to the appeal.

The order stipulated that interveners could not raise new issues and that affidavits filed in support of the motions were for contextual purposes only, not for adjudicative facts.