Claudia Jane Brabazon

The applicant, Simon Bridle, sought an O'Connor order for the production of third-party records (communications of Detective Inspector Patton of the Ontario Provincial Police) to support an allegation of improper preparation and communication by the police witness in prior pre-trial applications.

The court dismissed the application at Stage 1 of the O'Connor test, finding that the records were not likely relevant to any issue at trial, as DI Patton was not expected to testify at trial and her credibility was not a live issue.

The court also found the applicant's assertions of improper conduct to be speculative and based on misinterpretations of the cross-examination transcript.

The accused, Shaun Rootenberg, was charged with fraud over $5,000.00.

The defence brought an application for a stay of proceedings based on late disclosure and alleged abuse during pre-trial custody (strip searches).

The court dismissed the stay application, finding no prejudice from late disclosure and that the strip search complaints were not properly brought in the criminal forum.

On the fraud charge, the court found no deceit or falsehood in the initial investments by the complainant, Victoria Smith, but found the actus reus and mens rea of fraud established through "other fraudulent means" due to the unauthorized diversion of Ms. Smith's investment funds for personal use and to third parties.

Rootenberg was found guilty.