The plaintiff, a mortgage broker, brought a motion for summary judgment against the defendants, lawyers for the borrower, seeking $37,500 in unpaid broker fees.
The plaintiff alleged the defendants breached a trust by advancing the full mortgage funds to their client despite being notified of an error that included the broker fees.
The defendants argued there was no trust agreement with the plaintiff and they acted on their client's instructions.
The court dismissed the motion, finding no certainty of intention to create a trust and that the defendants did not act dishonourably by prioritizing their client's instructions.
The court also commented on the impropriety of a lawyer acting as both witness and counsel.