The plaintiff moved for summary judgment on liability arising from injuries sustained when a hotel balcony collapsed during wedding photographs.
The moving party argued that the collapse during ordinary use established the inn’s liability.
The defendant contended that the balcony was intended for far fewer occupants and raised contributory negligence based on evidence that the plaintiff had concerns about the balcony’s capacity before stepping onto it.
Applying the guidance in Combined Air Mechanical Services Inc. v. Flesch, the court held that determining contributory negligence and apportionment would require a full appreciation of the evidence that could not be achieved on a summary judgment record.
Because a trial would still be required to assess liability and apportionment, partial summary judgment was inappropriate.