The defendant in a personal injury action moved to compel the plaintiff to produce social media content (Facebook and Instagram) from three years pre-accident to present.
The plaintiff alleged severe injuries, including inability to wear high heels or dance, and loss of interest in social activities.
The defendant's private investigator obtained screen captures showing the plaintiff dancing and wearing high heels, contradicting her claims.
The court considered the relevance of social media content to the plaintiff's alleged physical limitations and enjoyment of life, balancing it against privacy interests.
It also addressed the requirement for leave to bring such a motion close to trial.
The motion was granted, ordering the plaintiff to produce electronic or paper copies of photographs from her Facebook and Instagram accounts.