G. Ackerley

Schindler Elevator Corporation brought an action to perfect a construction lien for unpaid services and materials supplied for the installation of elevators at the Women's College Hospital redevelopment project.

The general contractor, Walsh Construction/Bondfield Partnership (WBP), counterclaimed for delay impact losses, liquidated damages, and indemnification for penalties, alleging Schindler's delayed performance critically impacted the project schedule.

The court found that while Schindler breached the subcontract by delayed performance, WBP failed to prove that Schindler's delays impacted the critical path of the project or caused the majority of the claimed damages.

Schindler was awarded judgment for the unpaid subcontract balance, less minor set-offs for direct impacts, and WBP's claims against Schindler and its surety, Zurich, were dismissed.

Following the dismissal of the defendant's motion for partial summary judgment, the successful plaintiff sought costs on a partial indemnity scale.

The defendant argued the claimed amount was excessive and objected to the plaintiff's 'team approach' to the litigation.

The court found the division of labour reasonable but applied a discount to reflect the junior lawyers' experience and the fact that some work would apply to trial preparation.

Costs were fixed at $53,231.77 inclusive of fees, disbursements, and HST.

The owner of leased commercial premises moved under the Construction Lien Act to declare three construction liens invalid and to discharge security posted to vacate them, arguing the lien claimants failed to correctly identify the owner in their claims for lien.

The court considered whether the naming errors constituted non‑compliance with s. 34(5) of the Act or merely a failure to strictly comply curable under s. 6.

The evidence showed the tenant owner had used multiple corporate and unregistered names and had not registered certain business names, contributing to confusion about the proper legal entity.

The court held that the errors—misplacing the owner’s name in the electronic form or naming related Equinox entities—were failures to strictly comply but not fatal defects, and no prejudice was established.

Motions to discharge the liens were dismissed and the lien claimants were permitted to amend pleadings to correctly name the tenant owner.