/Adjudicator

minicounsel

Murray W. Chitra — Chair

Chair·Ontario Civilian Police Commission

Murray W. Chitra

Since 1994

119

cases · 17 yrs · OCPC

Trial

Motion

Costs

Appeal

Sentencing

Chair· 117Chair· 1Chair· 1

Detective Constable James Buckle v. Ontario Provincial Police, 2004 CanLII 77202

Statutory appeal of Hearing Officer's preliminary ruling dismissed as premature because the decision was interlocutory.

The appellant police officer sought to appeal two preliminary rulings by a Hearing Officer that denied his motions to dismiss disciplinary charges for failing to meet the six-month limitation period under section 69(18) of the Police Services Act.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission held that its jurisdiction under section 70(1) of the Act is limited to appeals of final decisions.

Because the Hearing Officer's rulings did not finally dispose of the disciplinary proceedings against the appellant, they were interlocutory.

The appeal was dismissed as premature.

OCPCDec 14, 2004

Buckle v. Ontario Provincial Police, 2004 CanLII 85031

Statutory appeal of preliminary disciplinary rulings dismissed as premature because the rulings were interlocutory, not final.

The appellant, a police officer, faced disciplinary charges for discreditable conduct related to a fire in a property room.

He brought preliminary motions before the Hearing Officer to dismiss the charges for failing to meet the six-month limitation period under section 69(18) of the Police Services Act.

The Hearing Officer dismissed the motions.

The appellant appealed these preliminary rulings to the Ontario Civilian Police Commission under section 70(1) of the Act.

The Commission held that its jurisdiction under section 70(1) is limited to appeals of final orders.

Because the Hearing Officer's rulings did not finally dispose of the disciplinary proceedings against the appellant, they were interlocutory.

Consequently, the appeal was deemed premature and dismissed, and the disciplinary hearing was directed to proceed.

OCPCDec 14, 2004

Mancini v. Courage and Niagara Police Service, 2004 ONCPC 11

Police officer reprimanded and docked 25 hours' pay for discreditable conduct involving unwanted contact with ex-partner.

The appellant appealed a hearing officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

The Commission previously revoked that finding and substituted a determination of guilt, finding the respondent engaged in a vexatious course of conduct by repeatedly contacting the appellant after their relationship ended, including while on duty and in uniform.

In this penalty decision, the Commission weighed the respondent's 28-year unblemished record against the seriousness of the misconduct.

The Commission ordered that the respondent be reprimanded and lose 25 hours of pay, which cannot be satisfied by applying accumulated credits.

OCPCOct 13, 2004

Susan Mancini v. Martin Courage, 2004 CanLII 76811

Police officer reprimanded and docked 25 hours' pay for discreditable conduct involving unwanted contact with former partner.

The appellant appealed a hearing officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

In this penalty decision, the Commission weighed the respondent's lengthy positive work record against the seriousness of the misconduct.

The Commission ordered that the respondent be reprimanded and lose 25 hours of pay, which cannot be satisfied by applying accumulated credits.

OCPCOct 13, 2004

Susan Mancini v. Constable Martin Courage, 2004 CanLII 77192

Police officer reprimanded and docked 25 hours' pay for discreditable conduct involving unwanted contact with former partner.

The appellant appealed a Hearing Officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

The Commission previously revoked the finding and substituted a determination of guilt, finding the respondent engaged in vexatious behaviour by repeatedly contacting the appellant after their relationship ended, despite warnings from superior officers.

In this penalty decision, the Commission considered the respondent's lengthy positive work record and the seriousness of the misconduct.

The Commission ordered that the respondent be reprimanded and lose 25 hours of pay, which cannot be satisfied by accumulated credits.

OCPCOct 13, 2004

Mancini v. Courage and Niagara Regional Police, 2004 ONCPC 9

Hearing Officer's acquittal revoked; police officer convicted of discreditable conduct for unwanted contact with ex-partner.

The appellant appealed a Hearing Officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

The respondent had engaged in a course of unwanted contact with the appellant following the end of their relationship, including attending her workplace and home while on duty and in uniform, despite being counseled by superior officers to stay away.

The Commission denied a motion to introduce fresh evidence.

On the merits, the Commission found the Hearing Officer erred by applying subjective elements to the test for discreditable conduct.

Applying the objective standard of the reasonable expectations of the community, the Commission revoked the finding of not guilty and substituted a conviction for discreditable conduct.

OCPCAug 12, 2004

Mancini v. Courage, 2004 CanLII 76810

Police officer convicted of discreditable conduct on appeal for unwanted contact with former partner.

The appellant appealed a Hearing Officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

The respondent had engaged in a course of unwanted contact with the appellant following the end of their relationship, including attending her workplace while on duty and having a child deliver a letter to her home.

The Commission found the Hearing Officer erred by applying subjective elements, such as the appellant's state of mind and the opinions of superior officers, rather than the objective test of whether the conduct would likely discredit the police service.

The Commission revoked the not guilty finding and substituted a conviction for discreditable conduct.

OCPCAug 12, 2004

Susan Mancini v. Constable Martin Courage, 2004 CanLII 77199

Hearing Officer's acquittal of police officer for discreditable conduct revoked and conviction substituted.

The appellant appealed a Hearing Officer's decision finding the respondent police officer not guilty of discreditable conduct.

The respondent had engaged in a course of unwanted contact with the appellant following the end of their relationship, including attending her workplace and having a child deliver a note to her home while he was on duty.

The Commission found that the Hearing Officer erred by applying subjective elements to the objective test for discreditable conduct.

The Commission revoked the finding of not guilty and substituted a conviction for discreditable conduct.

OCPCAug 12, 2004

Younan v. Ontario Provincal Police, 2004 ONCPC 3

Appeal of interlocutory ruling in police disciplinary hearing dismissed as premature.

The appellant police officer appealed an interlocutory ruling made by a Hearing Officer during a disciplinary hearing.

The Hearing Officer had ruled that the appellant must elect whether to call evidence before a motion for non-suit could be decided.

The Ontario Civilian Commission on Police Services dismissed the appeal as premature, holding that under section 70(1) of the Police Services Act, it only has jurisdiction to hear appeals of final decisions, not interlocutory procedural rulings.

OCPCMay 6, 2004

Sergeant Michael Younan v. Ontario Provincial Police, 2004 CanLII 77190

Appeal of interlocutory non-suit ruling in police discipline hearing dismissed as premature.

The appellant police officer appealed an interlocutory ruling by a Hearing Officer in a disciplinary proceeding.

The Hearing Officer had required the appellant to elect whether to call evidence before ruling on a motion for non-suit.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission dismissed the appeal as premature, finding that its appellate jurisdiction under section 70(1) of the Police Services Act is restricted to final orders.

The Commission also provided guidance that motions for non-suit in administrative proceedings should follow the civil procedure requiring a defendant to elect whether to call evidence.

OCPCMay 6, 2004

Sergeant Michael Younan v. Ontario Provincial Police, 2004 CanLII 85028

Appeal of interlocutory ruling on non-suit motion dismissed as premature under the Police Services Act.

The appellant police officer appealed an interlocutory decision of a Hearing Officer requiring him to elect whether to call evidence before ruling on a motion for non-suit in a disciplinary hearing.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission dismissed the appeal, finding that its jurisdiction under section 70(1) of the Police Services Act is restricted to appeals of final orders.

The Commission also provided guidance that the procedure for motions for non-suit in administrative proceedings conforms with civil court practice, requiring the defendant to elect whether to call evidence.

OCPCMay 6, 2004

Humphries v. Kelly and Durham Regional Police, 2003 CanLII 87668

Police discipline appeal dismissed; officer's acquaintance with witness did not create reasonable apprehension of bias.

The appellant appealed a decision finding Constable Kelly not guilty of neglect of duty under the Police Services Act.

The appellant alleged that Constable Kelly failed to conduct a thorough and impartial investigation into a domestic dispute because he was an acquaintance of the appellant's ex-wife's new partner.

The Commission dismissed the appellant's motion to introduce fresh evidence.

The Commission upheld the Hearing Officer's decision, finding no manifest error in the conclusion that Constable Kelly's actions did not constitute clear and convincing evidence of neglect of duty, and that the threshold for a reasonable apprehension of bias was not met.

OCPCAug 26, 2003

Lance Humphries v. Constable Bruce Kelly and Durham Regional Police Service, 2003 CanLII 75458

Appeal of police disciplinary decision dismissed; no manifest error in finding officer not guilty of neglect of duty.

The appellant appealed a Hearing Officer's decision finding a police constable not guilty of neglect of duty.

The appellant alleged the constable failed to conduct a thorough and impartial investigation into a domestic dispute, citing the constable's prior acquaintance with a witness and failure to interview a nanny.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission dismissed the appeal, finding no manifest error in the Hearing Officer's conclusions that the constable had reasonable grounds to arrest the appellant under the existing domestic violence policy and that the threshold for a reasonable apprehension of bias was not met.

OCPCAug 26, 2003

Lance Humphries v. Constable Bruce Kelly and Durham Regional Police Service, 2003 CanLII 85801

Appeal of police disciplinary decision dismissed; officer's investigation of domestic dispute did not constitute neglect of duty.

The appellant appealed a decision finding a police officer not guilty of neglect of duty.

The appellant alleged the officer failed to conduct a thorough and impartial investigation into a domestic dispute, citing the officer's prior acquaintance with a witness and failure to interview a nanny.

The Commission dismissed the appellant's motion to introduce fresh evidence, finding it did not meet the Palmer test.

The Commission upheld the Hearing Officer's decision, concluding there was no manifest error in finding the officer's actions did not constitute neglect of duty and that the threshold for a reasonable apprehension of bias was not met.

OCPCAug 26, 2003

Constable Kevin Brannagan v. Peel Regional Police Service, 2003 CanLII 85799

Police discipline appeal dismissed; notice of hearing was served within the six-month limitation period.

The appellant police officer appealed a conviction for neglect of duty, arguing that the disciplinary proceedings were barred by the six-month limitation period under section 69(18) of the Police Services Act.

The respondent argued the appeal itself was out of time under section 70(1).

The Commission held that the Notice of Hearing was served within the six-month limitation period, which commenced when the investigator received the officer's notes and formulated the opinion that misconduct occurred.

The Commission also held that the appeal was timely because the officer never received proper written notice of the hearing officer's decision on the limitation motion.

The conviction for neglect of duty was confirmed.

OCPCAug 25, 2003

Geske v. Hamilton Police Service, 2003 CanLII 87657

Police officer's appeal allowed; convictions for neglect of duty and deceit overturned due to lack of evidence.

The appellant police officer appealed a hearing officer's decision finding him guilty of one count of neglect of duty and two counts of deceit, which resulted in his dismissal.

The charges stemmed from allegations that he malingered on calls, made false statements to his supervisor about his activities, and destroyed a computer disk containing records.

The Ontario Civilian Commission on Police Services allowed the appeal and overturned all convictions.

The Commission found no evidence to support the malingering charge, noting the hearing officer accepted the officer's logs showing he was patrolling.

The Commission also found no evidence of intent to mislead regarding the statements, and concluded the destruction of the computer disk was done in accordance with established police practice.

OCPCJul 3, 2003

Constable Richard Geske v. Hamilton Police Service, 2003 CanLII 75457

Police officer's disciplinary convictions for neglect of duty and deceit overturned due to lack of evidence.

The appellant police officer appealed convictions for neglect of duty and deceit, and the resulting penalty of dismissal.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission allowed the appeal and overturned all convictions.

The Commission found no evidence to support the neglect of duty charge, noting the Hearing Officer's contradictory findings regarding the officer's notes.

The Commission also found no evidence of intent to mislead to support the first deceit charge, and concluded the officer had a lawful excuse for destroying a computer disk as he was following established practice.

OCPCJul 3, 2003

Geske v. Hamilton Police Service, 2003 CanLII 85814

Police officer's disciplinary convictions for neglect of duty and deceit overturned due to lack of evidence.

The appellant police officer appealed convictions for neglect of duty and deceit, as well as the resulting penalty of dismissal.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission allowed the appeal and overturned all convictions.

The Commission found no evidence to support the finding of malingering, noting a contradiction in the Hearing Officer's conclusions regarding the officer's notes.

Furthermore, the Commission held that the prosecution failed to prove the requisite intent to mislead for the deceit charges, and that the officer had a lawful excuse for destroying a computer disk in accordance with established practice.

OCPCJul 3, 2003

Kyle v. York Regional Police Service, 2003 CanLII 87675

Police officer's appeal of demotion penalty for off-duty impaired driving and racially motivated assault dismissed.

The appellant police officer appealed a disciplinary penalty of demotion to sergeant for one year, after which he would be required to compete for promotion to his former rank of staff sergeant.

The penalty arose from off-duty conduct resulting in criminal convictions for impaired driving and assault, during which the appellant used racial slurs against a citizen.

The appellant argued the indeterminate nature of the demotion was illegal under the Police Services Act and was harsh and excessive.

The Commission dismissed the appeal, finding that the Act permits a hearing officer to specify a demotion period that requires an officer to meet normal promotional requirements, and that the penalty was appropriate given the serious nature of the misconduct.

OCPCMar 11, 2003

Staff Sergeant Kenneth Kyle v. York Regional Police Service, 2003 CanLII 75461

Police disciplinary penalty of demotion with requirement to compete for promotion upheld as legal and appropriate.

The appellant, a police officer, appealed a disciplinary penalty of demotion to sergeant for one year, followed by a requirement to compete for promotion to his former rank of staff sergeant.

The penalty arose from off-duty conduct involving impaired driving, racial slurs, and assault, for which he received criminal convictions.

The appellant argued the indeterminate nature of the demotion was illegal under section 68(1)(c) of the Police Services Act and was harsh and excessive.

The Ontario Civilian Police Commission dismissed the appeal, finding that the statutory language permitting a hearing officer to specify the 'manner and period' of demotion includes requiring an officer to meet normal promotional requirements, and that the penalty was appropriate given the serious misconduct.

OCPCMar 11, 2003

Page 3 of 6 (119 cases)

Acting Chair, Hanover Police Services Board

Barbara BurkeAgent
1 appearance

Advisor, Policing Services Division, Ministry of the Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Dennis PlayerAgent
1 appearance

Appellant

Wayne PennerSelf-represented
3 appearances
Lance HumphriesSelf-represented
2 appearances

Chair, Clinton Police Services Board

Ron McKayAgent
1 appearance

Chair, Goderich Police Services Board

Rick MagieAgent
1 appearance

Chair, Walkerton Police Services Board

Don CarrollAgent
1 appearance

Chief, Goderich Police Service

George LonsbaryAgent
1 appearance

Chief, Hanover Police Service

Robert MajorAgent
1 appearance

Chief, Walkerton Police Service

Burrell GailingAgent
1 appearance

Citizen

Terry SpencerSelf-represented
2 appearances
Derek GreenSelf-represented
1 appearance
Heather GazeSelf-represented
1 appearance
Margery WenkoffSelf-represented
1 appearance
Ellen CraeymeerschSelf-represented
1 appearance
Claudette LaroqueSelf-represented
1 appearance

Co-Chair, Amalgamation Steering Committee

Rob McInnisAgent
1 appearance
Keith MayhewAgent
1 appearance

Counsel for Constable Bruce Kelly

William R. MacKenzieCounsel
2 appearances

Counsel for Constables Nathan Parker and Paul Koscinski

Gary R. ClewleyCounsel
2 appearances

Counsel for Deputy Chief Wayne Tremble

D. Alan WhyteCounsel
1 appearance

Counsel for Detective Constable James Buckle

Gavin J. MayCounsel
1 appearance

Counsel for Durham Regional Police Service

Brian FazackerleyAgent
2 appearances

Counsel for Niagara Regional Police Service

Woodward B. McKaigCounsel
2 appearances

Counsel for Ontario Provincial Police

Ted CarletonCounsel
1 appearance

Counsel for the Appellant

Harry G. Black, Q.C.Counsel
2 appearances
Andrew McKayCounsel
1 appearance
Irwin KoziebrockiCounsel
1 appearance
Jonathan D. CockerCounsel
1 appearance
W. Michael Temple, Q.C.Counsel
1 appearance

Counsel for the Respondent

Darragh MeagherCounsel
1 appearance
Elizabeth CowieCounsel
1 appearance
Ian D. ScottCounsel
1 appearance
John ZarudnyCounsel
1 appearance
Marnie BacherCounsel
1 appearance

Counsel to the Commission

Dennis BrownCounsel
1 appearance

for Appellant

Ian J. RolandCounsel
1 appearance

for Appellant and Respondent on Motion

Joanne MulcahyCounsel
2 appearances

for Brant County Police Association

Harold CoffinAgent
1 appearance

for Brant County Police Service

John CainAgent
1 appearance

for Brant County Police Services Board

Bill CroomeAgent
1 appearance

for Chatham-Kent

William EricksonAgent
1 appearance

for Chief Alex Balazs

Steven M. BoorneCounsel
1 appearance

for Chief Barry Reginald Moyle

James R. CaskeyCounsel
1 appearance

for Collingwood Police Association

John TrudeUnion representative
1 appearance

for Collingwood Police Service

Kenneth RobbAgent
1 appearance

for Collingwood Police Services Board

Bob SmithAgent
1 appearance

for Collingwood Senior Officers Association

Marilyn EmmersonUnion representative
1 appearance

for Committee of Citizens for Joint Policing

Cliff CarrAgent
1 appearance

for Constable Bettes

Bruce R. ShiltonCounsel
1 appearance

for Constable Bruce Kelly

William R. MacKenzieCounsel
1 appearance

for Constable Hewitson

D. GraceCounsel
1 appearance

for Constable Neil Gonzalez

Lorna E. BoydCounsel
2 appearances

for Constables Nathan Parker and Paul Koscinski

Gary R. ClewleyCounsel
4 appearances

for County of Brant

Ron EddyAgent
1 appearance

for Detective Constable James Buckle

Gavin J. MayCounsel
2 appearances

for Durham Regional Police Service

Brian FazackerleyAgent
1 appearance

for Fergus Police Association

Richard RookeUnion representative
1 appearance

for Harriston Police Association

Juanita DraperUnion representative
1 appearance

for Harriston Police Service

Ron FaulknerAgent
1 appearance

for Leamington Police Association

Allan KingUnion representative
1 appearance

for Leamington Police Service

John MacKinnonAgent
1 appearance

for Leamington Police Services Board

Don NicholsonAgent
1 appearance

for Meaford Police Association

Mike StylesUnion representative
1 appearance

for Meaford Police Service

Dennis FreebornAgent
1 appearance
Stephen BirchallAgent
1 appearance

for Meaford Police Service Board

Murray JolleyAgent
1 appearance

for Mersea Township Police Association

Kevin O’NeilUnion representative
1 appearance

for Mersea Township Police Service

Dean GowAgent
1 appearance

for Ministry of the Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Maurice HodgsonAgent
1 appearance
C. F. (Bud) BrennanAgent
1 appearance

for Niagara Regional Police Service

Woodward B. McKaigCounsel
4 appearances

for Ontario Provincial Police

Jinan KubursiCounsel
3 appearances
Ted CarletonCounsel
2 appearances
Harry deWoldeAgent
1 appearance
Bill HoldawayAgent
1 appearance
Paul PowersAgent
1 appearance

for Palmerston Police Association

Henry HeidingaUnion representative
1 appearance

for Palmerston Police Service

Eric KnudsenAgent
1 appearance

for Palmerston Police Services Board

Michael E. MitchellCounsel
1 appearance

for Peel Regional Police Service

Inspector Bert JohnsonAgent
1 appearance

for Police Services Boards and Municipal Councils of Port Elgin and Southampton

George MagwoodCounsel
1 appearance

for Policing Services Division, Ministry of Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Dennis PlayerAgent
1 appearance

for Respondent

Anthea E. MillikinCounsel
1 appearance
Christopher G. Riggs, Q.C.Counsel
1 appearance

for Sergeant Dalton Brown

Lorna E. BoydCounsel
1 appearance

for Southampton Police Association

Larry CooperUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Appellant

Gavin J. MayCounsel
6 appearances
Bruce RobertsonCounsel
6 appearances
Harry G. BlackCounsel
5 appearances
Harry G. Black, Q.C.Counsel
4 appearances
Jonathan D. CockerCounsel
3 appearances
Beth SymesCounsel
3 appearances
David ButtCounsel
3 appearances
Gary R. ClewleyCounsel
3 appearances
Ken JullCounsel
3 appearances
Lorna E. BoydCounsel
3 appearances
Martin DoaneCounsel
3 appearances
Michael W. MillerCounsel
3 appearances
Wayne PennerSelf-represented
3 appearances
Irwin KoziebrockiCounsel
2 appearances
Peter M. BrautiCounsel
2 appearances
Joanne E. MulcahyCounsel
2 appearances
Joanne MulcahyCounsel
2 appearances
W. Michael Temple, Q.C.Counsel
2 appearances
C. Justin GriffinCounsel
2 appearances
Ian RolandCounsel
1 appearance

for the Appellant (Respondent on Motion)

Lawrence Ben-EliezerCounsel
1 appearance

for the Applicant

Moishe ReiterCounsel
2 appearances
Michael PrattUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Chatham-Kent Police Services Board

Doug ArbourAgent
1 appearance

for the Chatham Police

Don RoskampAgent
1 appearance

for the Chatham Police Service

Carl HerderAgent
1 appearance

for the Chief, Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Service

Laurie VechterCounsel
1 appearance

for the City of Guelph

Trisha SinclairCounsel
1 appearance

for the City of Ottawa

Bruce H. Stewart, Q.C.Counsel
1 appearance

for the City of Woodstock

Patrice HilderleyAgent
1 appearance
Phil PooleAgent
1 appearance

for the Dresden Police Service

Edmund MacLeanAgent
1 appearance

for the East Zorra-Tavistock Police Services Board

Stephen CahillAgent
1 appearance

for the Guelph Police Services Board

Harry PeretsCounsel
1 appearance

for the Haldimand-Norfolk Regional Police Association

Dennis LeighUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Haldimand-Norfolk Regional Police Senior Officers Association

Gordon W. LittleUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Haldimand-Norfolk Regional Police Service

Warren BurgerAgent
1 appearance

for the Haldimand-Norfolk Regional Police Services Board

William HoskinsAgent
1 appearance
Woodward B. McKaigCounsel
1 appearance

for the Hawkesbury Police Association

Claude BoileauUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Hawkesbury Police Service

Jacques LaflammeAgent
1 appearance
Joffre DupuisAgent
1 appearance

for the Intervenor

George S. MonteithCounsel
2 appearances

for the Kemptville Police Association

Gordon McAinshUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Kemptville Police Service

Chris McCurleyAgent
1 appearance

for the Kemptville Police Services Board and Town of Kemptville

Russell TrivettAgent
1 appearance

for the Meaford Police Service Board

J.H.E. Middlebro'Counsel
1 appearance

for the Metropolitan Toronto Police Service

Thomas DalzielAgent
1 appearance

for the Ministry of Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Shelagh MorrisAgent
2 appearances
Bart CaronAgent
1 appearance

for the Ministry of the Solicitor General

Maurice HodgsonAgent
1 appearance
Paul SweetAgent
1 appearance

for the Ministry of the Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Maurice HodgsonAgent
1 appearance
Michael MitchellAgent
1 appearance

for the Niagara Regional Police Senior Officers Association

Robert SauderUnion representative
1 appearance

for the North Grenville Police Services Board

Reid HaddenAgent
1 appearance

for the North Grenville Police Services Board and Township of North Grenville

Bruce HarrisonAgent
1 appearance

for the Ontario Association of Police Services Boards

Michael HinesCounsel
1 appearance

for the Ontario Civilian Commission on Police Services

Leslie M. McIntoshCounsel
1 appearance

for the Ontario Provincial Police

David DonAgent
1 appearance
Inspector Bill DennisAgent
1 appearance
J. Brent HillAgent
1 appearance
Michael ShardAgent
1 appearance
Mike AhoAgent
1 appearance
Norm DenckertAgent
1 appearance
Richard CazabonAgent
1 appearance
Richard C. DeeringAgent
1 appearance
Rod CaseAgent
1 appearance
Staff Sergeant Ray DavisAgent
1 appearance

for the Ottawa Police Association

Allan R. O’BrienCounsel
1 appearance

for the Ottawa Police Services Board

John R. ReadCounsel
1 appearance

for the Police Association of Ontario

Ian RolandCounsel
1 appearance

for the Police Services Boards and Town Councils of Meaford and Thornbury

Brian RenkenCounsel
1 appearance

for the Police Task Force

Gerry WoltingAgent
1 appearance

for the Regional Council

John HarrisonAgent
1 appearance

for the Regional Municipality of Peel Police Services Board

Paul S. JarvisCounsel
1 appearance

for the Renfrew Police Association

Bryan H. PattersonUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Renfrew Police Service

Bob ThompsonAgent
1 appearance

for the Renfrew Police Services Board

Audrey GreenAgent
1 appearance
Lynda A. BordeleauCounsel
1 appearance

for the Respondent

Ian D. ScottCounsel
7 appearances
Robert FredericksCounsel
6 appearances
Brian R. SimpsonCounsel
6 appearances
Marnie BacherCounsel
6 appearances
Brian DuxburyCounsel
3 appearances
Elizabeth CowieCounsel
3 appearances
George S. MonteithCounsel
3 appearances
Jinan KubursiCounsel
3 appearances
Lorenzo D. PolicelliCounsel
3 appearances
Ted CarltonCounsel
3 appearances
Visha SukdeoCounsel
2 appearances
Ian SolomonCounsel
2 appearances
Jordana JosephCounsel
2 appearances
Carrie KitchuraCounsel
2 appearances
Michael ShardAgent
2 appearances
Sheila SchweizerCounsel
2 appearances
George MonteithCounsel
2 appearances
David McLeanAgent
1 appearance
Tom HughesAgent
1 appearance
Lynda A. BordeleauCounsel
1 appearance

for the Respondent and Applicant on Motion

Elizabeth CowieCounsel
2 appearances

for the Respondent (Applicant on Motion)

Ian SolomonCounsel
1 appearance

for the Respondent, Nicola Aylin

Kelley J. BryanCounsel
2 appearances

for the Respondents

Harry G. BlackCounsel
2 appearances

for the Respondent, Toronto Police Service

Robert FredericksCounsel
2 appearances

for the St. Clair Beach Police Association

Sergeant Rick TonialUnion representative
1 appearance

for the St. Clair Beach Police Service

Michael SmithAgent
1 appearance

for the Tavistock Police Service

Alex BalazsAgent
1 appearance

for the Tecumseh Police Services Board

Ken TowersAgent
1 appearance
Tom FuerthAgent
1 appearance

for the Tilbury Police Association

Doug GoldsmithUnion representative
1 appearance

for the Tilbury Police Service

Jack ChambersAgent
1 appearance

for the Town Council of Goderich and the Goderich Police Services Board

D.J. MurphyAgent
1 appearance

for the Town of Goderich

D.J. MurphyCounsel
1 appearance

for the Town of Hawkesbury

Gilbert HérouxAgent
1 appearance
Lucien BerniquezAgent
1 appearance

for the Town of Renfrew

Sandra J. HeinsAgent
1 appearance

for the Town of Tecumseh

Ed RenaudAgent
1 appearance
Gerald SykesAgent
1 appearance

for the Township of Blandford-Blenheim

Don WoolcottAgent
1 appearance
Keith ReiblingAgent
1 appearance

for the Township of East Zorra-Tavistock

Dave OliphantAgent
1 appearance

for the Township of North Grenville and North Grenville Police Services Board

Donald CameronAgent
1 appearance

for the Township of Norwich and County of Oxford

Mark HarrisonAgent
1 appearance

for the Township of Norwich Police Services Board

Larry HillAgent
1 appearance

for the Walkerton and Hanover Police Services

George C. MagwoodCounsel
1 appearance

for the Wallaceburg Police Association and Police Association of Ontario

Ian J. RolandCounsel
1 appearance
Martin J. DoaneCounsel
1 appearance

for the Wallaceburg Police Service

Del LunnAgent
1 appearance

for the Wallaceburg Police Services Board

Daryn M. JeffriesCounsel
1 appearance
David I. WakelyCounsel
1 appearance

for the Woodstock Police Association, Woodstock Senior Officers Association, Township of Norwich Police Association and Township of Norwich Senior Officers Association

Martin DoaneCounsel
1 appearance

for the Woodstock Police Service

Joe OpthofAgent
1 appearance
Ron FraserAgent
1 appearance

for the Woodstock Police Services Board

Sandra TalbotAgent
1 appearance

for Thornbury Police Association

Charles WattsUnion representative
1 appearance

for Thornbury Police Service

John OrmesherAgent
1 appearance

for Thornbury Police Service Board

Jim UramAgent
1 appearance

for Town of Leamington

Dave WilkinsonAgent
1 appearance

for Town of Meaford

Iris ShakellAgent
1 appearance

for Township of Mersea

Robert SchmidtAgent
1 appearance

for Wellington County Police Services Board

Barbara TocherAgent
1 appearance
Clarke MelvilleAgent
1 appearance
Murray LangdonAgent
1 appearance
Rob GilbertAgent
1 appearance
Scott WilsonAgent
1 appearance

Grenville County Ontario Provincial Police

Brent HillAgent
1 appearance

Hanover Constable speaking as a private citizen

Phillip SchuesslerSelf-represented
1 appearance

Hanover Senior Officers Association

Wendy SurridgeUnion representative
1 appearance

Inspector, Ontario Provincial Police

Doug ShearerAgent
1 appearance
W. E. TrachselAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Exeter

Ben HoogenboomAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Goderich

D.J. ShewfeltAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Hanover

Bob WhiteAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Kincardine

Charles MannAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Mitchell

Hugh McCaugheyAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Seaforth

Irwin JohnstonAgent
1 appearance

Mayor, Town of Walkerton

James BoldenAgent
1 appearance

Ontario Provincial Police

Jinan KubursiCounsel
1 appearance

Police Association of Ontario

Bruce MillerUnion representative
1 appearance

Policing Services Adviser, Ministry of the Solicitor General and Correctional Services

Maurice HodgsonAgent
1 appearance

Prescott Police Association

Martin DoaneCounsel
1 appearance

Prescott Police Service

F.A. (Rick) BowieAgent
1 appearance
Gerry W. RingAgent
1 appearance
Joseph ScottAgent
1 appearance

Prescott Police Services Board

Gordon MillsAgent
1 appearance
Lynda A. BordeleauCounsel
1 appearance

President, Hanover Police Association

John CustodeUnion representative
1 appearance

President, Walkerton Police Association

Ron ShaidleUnion representative
1 appearance

Resident, Town of Goderich

Bud OkeSelf-represented
1 appearance
Donald KernickSelf-represented
1 appearance
James Eric KirkSelf-represented
1 appearance

Secretary, Amalgamation Steering Committee

Sherry AnstettAgent
1 appearance

Sergeant, Goderich Police Service

Peter MasonAgent
1 appearance

Sergeant, Ontario Provincial Police

G. W. MixAgent
1 appearance
Ray DavisAgent
1 appearance

Staff Sergeant, Ontario Provincial Police

Don McInnesAgent
1 appearance

Town of Prescott

Garry DewarAgent
1 appearance

Treasurer, Town of Goderich

Luke GagnonAgent
1 appearance

unknown

John BrickerSelf-represented
1 appearance

Vice President, Goderich Police Association

Ken BrownleeAgent
1 appearance

119

Decisions

Years active

Tribunals

1994–2010

Active range

OCPC119(100%)

Decision types

appeal

motion

trial

Page 3 of 6 (119 cases)