Raymond Zar

The court-appointed Receiver brought multiple motions seeking various forms of relief, including a declaration of vacant possession and writ of possession for a condominium unit (PH 07), approval and vesting orders (AVOs) for the sale of two specific condominium units (PH 02 and PH 03), prospective AVOs for five remaining units subject to sale conditions, approval of certain distributions from sale proceeds, approval of the Receiver's activities, and a sealing order for confidential appendices.

The applicant, KingSett Mortgage Corporation, and CIBC supported the relief.

The respondent, 30 Roe Investments Corp., represented by its president and personal guarantor, Raymond Zar, opposed some aspects, particularly the pre-approval of sales for remaining units without the debtor's consent and the immediate payment of HST.

The court granted most of the Receiver's requests, finding no lawful right for the occupant of PH 07, approving the sales under specific conditions, and approving distributions, with a temporary deferral on the HST payment issue to allow the respondent to provide supporting documentation.

The court-appointed receiver, KSV Restructuring Inc., moved to quash an appeal by the debtor, 30 Roe Investments Corp., from orders approving the sale of two condominium units. 30 Roe argued the units should be sold en bloc, not individually, and that the sales diminished the "Enterprise" value.

The Court of Appeal found no appeal as of right under BIA s. 193(a)-(c) as the appeal did not involve future rights, did not directly involve property value loss (as the sales were at market price and the en bloc argument was a collateral attack on prior unappealed orders), and was not likely to affect other similar cases.

The court also denied leave to appeal under BIA s. 193(e), finding the issue not of general importance, not prima facie meritorious, and unduly hindering the receivership.

The appeal was quashed, and leave to appeal denied.