Katy O’Rourke

Following an order to merge two local unions into a larger local, the former locals attempted to amend their trust and building corporation documents to distribute assets pro rata to their members rather than transferring them to the merged local.

The court found these actions were taken without authorization, violated the union's constitution, and constituted a breach of fiduciary duty by the trustees and directors.

The court declared the amendments null and void, imposed a constructive trust, and ordered the assets transferred to the merged local.

Oxford Properties Group brought a motion seeking the appointment of a specific arbitrator to determine the current value of the Newmarket Property under an option agreement.

Sears Canada Inc. and its Monitor brought a cross-motion requesting the appointment of a different arbitrator, who was already acting as a Claims Officer in the CCAA proceedings, to determine both the property's value and Oxford's related disputed claims.

The court found the issues to be inextricably linked and that separate proceedings would lead to additional cost and delay.

The court granted the cross-motion, appointing the arbitrator proposed by Sears and the Monitor to resolve all outstanding issues related to the property in a single, consolidated proceeding, thereby dismissing Oxford's motion.