John Richardson

Following the dismissal of its application to prevent the re-leasing of disputed lands, the applicant condominium corporation argued it should be relieved of costs because the matter was in the public interest and involved consumer protection.

The court rejected these arguments, holding that condominium corporations are subject to the standard costs regime.

The court awarded partial indemnity costs to the respondents, declining to award substantial indemnity costs based on an unaccepted monetary offer to settle because the application sought non-monetary relief.

Costs were fixed at $58,655.44 for two respondents and $35,008.44 for the third.

The applicant, York Condominium Corporation No. 76 (YCC76), sought to invalidate a lease amendment concerning "Disputed Lands" within the Crescent Town development.

YCC76 claimed a leasehold interest in the lands and alleged that the amendment, which released the lands in exchange for $500,000, was improperly approved by the board of Crescent Town Club Inc. (CTC) and constituted oppression.

The court dismissed YCC76's application, finding that YCC76 had no leasehold interest in the Disputed Lands, the board's approval was valid under the Ontario Not For Profit Corporations Act, 2010, and the lease did not require unanimous consent from YCC76.

Furthermore, the court determined it lacked broad jurisdiction to grant an oppression remedy under the ONCA, and even if it did, YCC76 failed to prove oppression or actual prejudice.