Ivan Merrow

The defendants in a certified class action regarding COVID-19 business interruption insurance claims brought a motion seeking joint adjudication and common case management of common questions across approximately 79 overlapping proceedings.

The motion was opposed by several plaintiffs in individual actions who wished to proceed independently.

The court dismissed the motion, affording deference to a prior case management decision that declined to stay the individual actions, and finding that forcing joint adjudication would inappropriately undermine the plaintiffs' right to opt out of the class proceeding and cause undue delay.

The appellants appealed the disallowance of their claims in a bankruptcy proposal proceeding.

They claimed a 20% beneficial interest in the proceeds of a commercial property sale based on an amended trust declaration, and advanced an unsecured claim for damages alleging oppressive conduct.

The court dismissed the appeal, finding no certainty of intention to create an express trust, no basis for a constructive trust, and no evidence of oppressive conduct by the bankrupt corporation.