Franz Lopez

The Ontario Land Tribunal held a Case Management Conference regarding appeals of a Municipal Order to Pay Costs issued by the Regional Municipality of Peel.

The order relates to spills from underground storage tanks at a gas station.

The appellants requested a motion to stay the proceedings pending the resolution of a related civil matter in the Ontario Superior Court.

The Tribunal scheduled a one-day motion hearing for October 10, 2025, and a second Case Management Conference for December 8, 2025.

The Crown sought leave to appeal a decision of the Ontario Court of Justice that overturned the respondent's conviction under the Endangered Species Act for damaging Blanding's turtle habitat.

The appeal judge had entered an acquittal after finding the circumstantial evidence of turtle sightings from prior and subsequent years insufficient to prove the land was habitat at the time of the offence.

The Court of Appeal held that while the appeal judge's conclusion raised a question of law alone, the Crown failed to demonstrate that granting leave was essential in the public interest or for the due administration of justice.

The decision below was highly fact-specific and unlikely to establish a binding precedent requiring direct evidence of habitat use.

Leave to appeal was denied, and the respondent's request for costs was dismissed.

At a Case Management Conference regarding appeals of an environmental compliance order concerning benzene emissions, three community members sought party status.

The Tribunal granted them party status under s. 145(1) of the Environmental Protection Act, finding their individual perspectives on health impacts would assist the adjudication.

The Tribunal also granted the appellant leave to amend its grounds for appeal in light of a new federal Interim Order and provincial regulation.