David McCutcheon

The appellant association appealed a Divisional Court decision dismissing its application for judicial review.

The respondent race track owner had excluded certain licensed members of the appellant from racing at its track, citing private property rights.

The Ontario Racing Commission declined jurisdiction to hold a hearing on the matter, believing it could not interfere with private property rights.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, holding that the Commission's broad statutory powers to govern and regulate horse racing in the public interest necessarily included the power to make decisions that incidentally affect private property rights.

The Commission was directed to hold a hearing.