The appellant trainer appealed a decision of the Stewards fining and suspending him after his horse tested positive for a prohibited substance, and for failing to maintain adequate medication records.
The Ontario Racing Commission allowed the appeal, finding that the trainer had established on a balance of probabilities that he took all reasonable care to protect the horse, and that the positive test likely resulted from an error by the treating veterinary hospital.
The Commission also found that the trainer's delegation of record-keeping to staff and reliance on hospital records satisfied the rules.
The fines and suspension were quashed, though the horse's disqualification remained.