Stefan Rus

This costs endorsement addresses the aftermath of a motion to strike the defendants’ statement of defence for failure to attend examinations for discovery.

The court had previously dismissed the motion to strike but awarded the plaintiffs partial costs thrown away.

The parties could not agree on costs, and both made written submissions.

The court ultimately found that, given the divided result and the defendants’ prior waiver of costs, each party should bear its own costs of the motion.

The plaintiffs brought a motion to strike the defendants' statement of defence and for costs thrown away after the defendants failed to attend scheduled examinations for discovery.

The court found that the defendants' non-attendance was due to their former counsel's inadvertent misunderstanding of the schedule, rather than a deliberate flouting of a court order.

The motion to strike was dismissed, as the draconian remedy was not warranted and the defendants offered to cure the default.

However, the court awarded the plaintiffs $15,823.77 in costs thrown away for the wasted preparation time and disbursements related to the missed examinations.