Court of Appeal for Ontario

Date: 2004-03-08

Docket: C37092

Re:

MAPLE VALLEY ACRES LIMITED Plaintiff (Respondent)

• and - CANADIAN IMPERIAL BANK OF COMMERCE AND KEYSER, MASON BALL Defendants (Appellant) (Respondent by Cross-Appeal)
• and - 620923 ONTARIO INC., ROBERT MACKAY, KALMAN CZEGLEDY, MICHAEL BASS, J.F.X. O’CONNELL, GARY S. WALTERS and FRASER & BEATTY

Before:

LASKIN, GOUDGE AND FELDMAN JJ.A.

Counsel:

Kevin R. Aalto and Patrick Eichenberg for the appellant

Thomas W. G. Pratt for the respondent Maple Valley

Kirk F. Stevens and Kirk Boggs for the respondent Keyser, Mason, Ball

Timothy P. D. Bates for the respondents Walters and Fraser & Beatty

Heard:

October 2, 2003

Reasons Released:

November 21, 2003

C O S T S E N D O R S E M E N T

[1] Having reviewed the submissions of parties costs of the appeal are awarded against the appellant on a partial indemnity basis as follows:

(a) in favour of the respondent Maple Valley Acres Limited $20,000;

(b) in of the respondent Keyser Mason Ball in the amount of $30,000;

(c) in favour of the respondent Fraser & Beatty and Gary S. Walters in the amount of $20,000.

"John Laskin J.A."

"S.T. Goudge J.A."

_ "K. Feldman J.A."