Marc A. Rodrigue

The court determined the costs award following a successful summary judgment motion for wrongful dismissal.

The plaintiff sought substantial indemnity costs of $52,000, while the defendant proposed $5,000 to $10,000.

The court initially adjusted the parties' agreed partial indemnity estimate of $35,000 to $30,000 due to both parties prolonging litigation.

Further adjustments were made for counsel's hourly rates and the simplified procedure rule, leading to a partial indemnity award of $27,500.

The plaintiff's Rule 49 offer did not trigger substantial indemnity due to an unpleaded human rights allocation and an insufficient differential in after-tax values.

The plaintiff, a long-term employee, was terminated for cause by the defendant employer, Best Buy, on grounds of conflict of interest and dishonesty.

The plaintiff moved for summary judgment for wrongful dismissal.

The court found that the employer failed to establish either ground for just cause.

The alleged conflict of interest (operating a competing repair service) was based on outdated ads and never materialized, and the accusation of reselling products for profit was unsubstantiated.

The dishonesty claim was also not proven, as the plaintiff's explanations were reasonable or related to a personal medical condition.

The court granted summary judgment, finding the plaintiff was wrongfully dismissed and entitled to 11 months' notice, calculating total damages.