Jillian Evans

The plaintiff was injured after colliding with an unlit street light pole on a sidewalk.

She initially sued the City of Toronto, believing it owned and maintained the pole.

Years later, she learned the City had sold the street lights to Toronto Hydro.

The plaintiff brought a motion to correct the defendant's name on the basis of misnomer.

The Master found that the 'litigating finger' was clearly pointed at the entity responsible for the pole, and granted the misnomer correction, awarding substantial indemnity costs to the plaintiff, although noting the decision was practically moot as a parallel appeal had already added Toronto Hydro as a defendant.

The moving defendant, an orthopedic surgeon, brought a motion for summary judgment to dismiss the medical malpractice action against him, arguing the limitation period had expired.

The plaintiffs brought a cross-motion to correct a misnomer, seeking to replace 'John Doe' with the moving defendant.

The court found that there was a genuine issue for trial regarding when the plaintiffs reasonably could have discovered the moving defendant's potential liability for delayed care.

Both the summary judgment motion and the misnomer cross-motion were dismissed, with the issues left to be determined by the trial judge.

The respondents in a Charter application brought a refusals motion seeking to compel three expert witnesses retained by the applicants to re-attend cross-examinations and produce draft affidavits and notes of communications with counsel.

The respondents argued that counsel's assistance in drafting the experts' affidavits raised reasonable grounds to question their independence, thereby waiving litigation privilege.

The court applied the principles from Moore v. Getahun and White Burgess, finding that consultation between counsel and experts is a necessary part of the adversarial process.

The court dismissed the motion, concluding there was no factual foundation to support a reasonable suspicion that counsel improperly influenced the experts.