Jesse Benjamin Kugler

In CCAA proceedings, the court issued a supplementary costs endorsement following an earlier costs decision.

The issue concerned whether the full amount of a law firm disbursement account should be added to the cost award.

After reviewing detailed particulars, the court found the discounted account represented fair value for services rendered and that the disbursements were reasonable.

The court approved inclusion of the full amount of the account as a disbursement and revised the total costs award accordingly.

Former directors sought declarations that claims advanced in a Quebec class action concerning pension losses were barred by releases granted during Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act proceedings.

The court held that it had jurisdiction to determine the motion because the dispute concerned the effect of orders and releases issued within the CCAA restructuring.

The contractual releases executed by the union on behalf of beneficiaries were broadly worded and applied to all claims relating to facts existing at the time of the release, whether known or unknown.

The court found that the claims process and releases extinguished any potential claims against the directors relating to the pension deficit.

Accordingly, the Quebec class action claims against the directors were fully and irrevocably released.