2 total
The court allowed the appeal and entered convictions, finding the trial judge erred by ignoring circumstantial evidence of corporate identity.
The Electrical Safety Authority appealed the acquittal of Turano’s Home Improvement Ltd. at trial.
The trial judge had acquitted the corporate defendant, finding that its identity was not proven beyond a reasonable doubt, primarily due to the absence of "Ltd" on the contract letterhead.
The appellate court found that the trial judge erred by focusing too narrowly on the letterhead and failing to consider the totality of the evidence, which included witness testimony and documentary evidence confirming the corporate entity's involvement.
The appeal was granted, and the corporate defendant was found guilty on the dismissed counts.
Motion for stay of registration revocation pending appeal dismissed; public interest outweighed private financial harm.
The appellants, a motor vehicle salesperson and a motor vehicle dealer, appealed a Tribunal decision directing the revocation of their registrations to the Divisional Court.
They brought a motion before the Tribunal for a stay of the revocation decision pending the outcome of their appeal.
Applying the RJR-MacDonald test, the Tribunal found that while there was a serious issue to be tried, the appellants failed to establish irreparable harm, as their anticipated financial losses and business closure could be quantified in monetary terms.
Furthermore, the balance of convenience favoured denying the stay, as the public interest in consumer protection outweighed the appellants' private commercial interests, given their history of non-compliance with registration conditions.
The motion for a stay was dismissed.
