2 total
Motions to intervene as party and friend of the court in environmental judicial review dismissed.
The Industry Coalition for Environmental Fairness Inc. (ICEF) and the Environmental Commissioner of Ontario brought motions for leave to intervene in a judicial review of an Environmental Review Tribunal decision.
The underlying judicial review concerned the test for leave to appeal under the Environmental Bill of Rights regarding certificates of approval issued to a cement company.
The court dismissed both motions, finding that ICEF lacked a direct interest and would not make a useful contribution without causing delay, and that the Environmental Commissioner's proposed intervention would not provide a different perspective from the existing parties and would likely prejudice them.
Judicial review of tribunal's interlocutory decision to strike a ground of appeal dismissed as premature.
The applicants sought judicial review of a decision by the Environmental Review Tribunal to quash one of their grounds of appeal.
The tribunal had previously granted leave to appeal a Director's order regarding nickel contamination in soil on only one of eight proposed grounds.
The Divisional Court dismissed the application for judicial review, finding that the tribunal had the jurisdiction to limit the scope of the appeal to the ground on which leave was granted.
The court also held that the application was premature, as it challenged an interlocutory procedural decision, and that the tribunal's decision was reasonable.
