The appellant appealed a judgment of the Court of Appeal of Quebec affirming the inadequacy of the trial judge's reasons.
A majority of the Court dismissed the appeal substantially for the reasons of the majority of the Court of Appeal concerning the inadequacy of the trial judge's reasons.
The dissenting judge would have allowed the appeal for the reasons given by the dissenting judge at the Court of Appeal.
The judgment was delivered orally on the day of hearing.
The Attorney General of Ontario intervened in the proceedings.
