Ahmed Hany Ibrahim Shafey

Following a contempt motion between the plaintiff and defendants, the court addressed costs.

Although the defendants successfully defended the contempt motion, the court found it more likely than not that one defendant removed certain logbooks in contravention of court orders, which militated against awarding costs to the defendants.

The plaintiff also failed on the motion and therefore was not entitled to costs.

However, a non-party that participated in the proceedings was awarded substantial indemnity costs due to its limited but necessary involvement.

The court ordered the plaintiff to pay the non-party $25,000 plus HST and disbursements.

The plaintiff brought a motion seeking a finding of contempt against the defendants and a non-party corporation for allegedly failing to comply with prior court orders requiring the delivery of aircraft engine logbooks.

The moving party argued the materials had been removed or withheld in breach of orders compelling their production.

The court held that contempt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and found the evidence against the non-party was entirely circumstantial with no plausible motive established.

While the evidence suggested it was possible the individual defendant removed the logbooks, the court concluded the record did not establish the allegation beyond a reasonable doubt due to alternative explanations and lack of direct evidence.

The contempt motion was dismissed.

Costs decision following two motions in an employment action alleging constructive dismissal and entitlement to a bonus.

The defendant successfully moved to set aside a noting in default and successfully resisted the plaintiff’s summary judgment motion concerning whether a bonus should be paid entirely in cash or partially through restricted share units.

The court found that plaintiff’s counsel improperly refused to consent to setting aside the noting in default, unnecessarily increasing litigation costs.

Substantial indemnity costs of $9,500 were awarded for the motion to set aside the noting in default.

Partial indemnity costs of $20,000 were awarded for the summary judgment motion.