William Swinburne Foster

This endorsement addresses a case management motion concerning outstanding follow-up questions from discovery and the timing of the plaintiff's expert report.

The plaintiff sought further answers from the defendant, TD Canada Trust, regarding security protocols and risk assessments following an alleged assault at an ATM vestibule.

The court applied principles of proportionality and finality, rejecting many of the plaintiff's requests for information deemed beyond the scope of appropriate discovery or based on information that should have been obtained earlier.

The court also found the plaintiff responsible for significant delays in the litigation and ordered the expert report to be produced promptly, with strict timelines, while allowing for a supplemental report if new information warranted it.

The Plaintiff sought leave to bring a Rule 30.10 motion for third-party records production from other banks, which the Defendant opposed.

The court found the Plaintiff's delay in bringing the motion unreasonable due to counsel's dilatory conduct in retaining and instructing an expert.

Despite the unreasonable delay and potential for further adjournment of the summary judgment motion, the court reluctantly granted leave to the Plaintiff to bring the motion on terms, including payment of costs to the Defendant, to avoid prejudicing the Plaintiff due to counsel's failures.