Court File and Parties

Court File No.: CV-15-530882 Date: 20190423 Superior Court of Justice - Ontario

Re: Diane Amy Martin and Frank Martin, Plaintiffs And: Ari Brafman, Shlomo Levkovich, 1390835 Ontario Limited c.o.b. as Toyota on Front and Co-Operators General Insurance Company, Defendants

Before: Mr. Justice Stephen E. Firestone

Counsel: Stacey L. Stevens, for the Plaintiffs Michael P. Taylor, for Defendant Ari Brafman Robert S. Sutherland, for the Defendants Shlomo Levkovich and 1390832 Ontario Limited c.o.b. as Toyota on Front Robert E. Sugar, for the Defendant The Co-Operators

Heard: In Writing

Endorsement

[1] The plaintiffs request that this action and actions CV-14-501886, CV-14-515957, CV-15, 534594-00A1, CV-14-515959 and CV-15-534591 (“the “actions”) be assigned for case management pursuant to rule 77.05 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, R.R.O.1990.Reg.194 (the “rules”).

[2] The Regional Senior Judge has delegated the responsibility for determining requests for case management to me as the Civil Team Leader-Toronto Region. I have reviewed the materials provided.

[3] On March 31, 2017, Master Pope ordered that these actions be tried at the same time, or one immediately after the other.

[4] In applying the criteria set forth in rule 77.05(4) to the factual matrix of these proceedings, I am satisfied that these actions should be assigned for case management.

[5] I order that actions CV-15-530882, CV-14-501886, CV-14-515957, CV-15-534594-00A1, CV-14-515959 and CV-15-534591 be assigned for case management and in accordance with rule 77.06(1) that Justice W.S. Chalmers be assigned as the case management judge.

Firestone J. Date: April 23, 2019