FOUR LAWYERS’ MOTION

COURT FILE NO.: C-2835-13

DATE: 2015/07/14

ONTARIO

SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE

BETWEEN:

S.F.

Plaintiff

– and –

THE GREATER SUDBURY POLICE SERVICE, THE SUDBURY POLICE SERVICES BOARD AND SUDBURY POLICE ASSOCIATION, M. PAQUETTE, CRAIG MAKI, ROBIN TIPLAY, M. JEFFERY, DAVID BECK, CRAIG MOXAM, TODD BIGNOCOLLO, DAN ZULIANNI, JEFF KUHN, SUSAN LEYS, TIM BURTT, J. ROBERTSON, L. MCLOSKY, T. MARASSATO, P. SMYTH, ELAINA GROVES, SANDRA DICAIRE, PAUL MCGEE, MEAGAN O’MALLEY, JACK SIVAZLIAN, DUNCAN EPP, M. ROBINSON, GREG BERGERON, FRANK ELSNER, CONST. ELDEAMA, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR ONTARIO, JOHN LUCZAK, KENDRICK ABBOTT, MERIEL ANDERSON, SUSAN BRUCE, MARC HUNEAULT, JOHN HOLLAND, LEILA MEHKERI, RUBY BECK, MICHEL J. MOREAU, MICHAEL G. KITLAR, SUSAN STOTHART, LEONARD KIM, DIANNE LAFLUER, ANDREA BEAL, RIA BIGNOCOLLO, HELENE BRYDGES, PIERRE BRADLEY LAW OFFICE, CHILDREN’S AID’S SOCIETY OF THE DISTRICTS OF SUDBURY AND MANITOULIN, JEAN JACQUES PAQUETTE, REJEAN PARISE, COLLETTE PREVOST, NORA DOUGAN, LINDA CULLAIN, JEAN O’CONNER, DARLENE WILSON, MICHELLE GLOVER, DONALD KINGSLEY, CANDICE POULIN, KAREN FAGEN, CHRISTY CROTEAU, DEBBIE LACELLE, LAURA FOX, JODY MARCOTTE, MS. BISAILLON, LOUISE BRENDA BEAUVAIS, JOSH NEGUSANTI, PATRICIA L. MEEHAN, MINISTRY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OFFICE OF THE CHILDREN’S LAWYER, SHEILA MILNE M.D., BRENDA PETRYNA, HEALTH PROFESSIONS APPEAL AND REVIEW BOARD, THE CHILD AND FAMILY SERVICES REVIEW BOARD, SUZANNE GILBERT and MR. OLIVER, OFFICE OF THE INDEPENDENT REVIEW DIRECTOR GERRY MCNEILLY, SUSAN DUNN-LUNDY, KIM MCDONALD, BERNIE MUILLER, TERESA PIRUZZA MINISTRY OF CHILD & YOUTH SERVICES, DEB MATHEWS MINISTRY OF HEALTH, RICK BARTOLUCCI MPP FOR SUDBURY ONTARIO, VICE CHAIR STANDING COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENT AGENCIES

Defendants

S.F., Unrepresented

G. E. McAndrew, for the defendants, PIERRE BRADLEY LAW OFFICE, JEAN JACQUES PAQUETTE, and PATRICIA L. MEEHAN, REJEAN PARISE, and

Carole G. Jenkins, for the defendants, Children’s Aid Society of the Districts of Sudbury and Manitoulin, Collette Prevost, Nora Dougan, Linda Cullain, Jean O’Connor, Darlene Wilson, Michelle Glover, Donald Kingsley, Candice Poulin, Karen Fagen, Christy Croteau, Debbie Lacelle, Laura Fox, Jody Marcotte, Louise Beauvais, Brenda Beauvais and Josh Negusanti, and

C. Kirk Boggs, for the defendants, THE GREATER SUDBURY POLICE SERVICE, THE SUDBURY POLICE SERVICES BOARD, M. PAQUETTE, CRAIG MAKI, ROBIN TIPLAY, M. JEFFERY, DAVID BECK, CRAIG MOXAM, TODD BIGNOCOLLO, DAN ZULIANNI, JEFF KUHN, SUSAN LEYS, TIM BURTT, J. ROBERTSON, L. MCCLOSKY, T. MARASSATO, P. SMYTH, ELAINA GROVES, SANDRA DICAIRE, PAUL MCGHEE, MEAGAN O’MALLEY, JACK SIVAZLIAN, DUNCAN EPP, M. ROBINSON, FRANK ELSNER, CONST. ELDEAMA, and

Meagan Williams and Baaba Forson, for the defendants, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF ONTARIO, JOHN LUCZAK, KENRICK ABBOTT, MURIEL ANDERSON, SUSAN BRUCE, MARC HUNEAULT, JOHN HOLLAND, LEILA MEHKERI, RUBY BECK, DIANE LAFLEUR, MICHEL J. MOREAU, MICHAEL G. KITLAR, SUSAN STOTHART, LEONARD KIM, ANGELLA BEAL, RIA BIGNUCOLO, HELEN BRYDGES, THE CHILD AND FAMILY SERVICES REVIEW BOARD, SUZANNE GILBERT, OLIVER URCUYO, OFFICE OF THE INDEPENDENT POLICE REVIEW DIRECTOR, GERRY MCNEILLY, SUSAN DUNN-LUNDY, KIM MCDONALD, BERNIE MUILLER, TERESA PIRUZZA, DEB MATTHEWS, RICK BARTOLUCCI, MINISTRY OF CHILDREN AND YOUTH SERVICES, MINISTRY OF HEALTH, MINISTRY OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL – OFFICE OF THE CHILDREN’S LAWYER, and

Michael C. Birnie, for the defendant, SUDBURY POLICE ASSOCIATION, and

Phuong T.V. Ngo and Madeline Hall, for the defendant, Sheila Milne M.D., and

David P. Jacobs and Steven G. Bosnick, for the defendants, Brenda Petryna, and Health Professions Appeal and Review Board, and

ms. Bisaillon and GREG BERGERON, unrepresented defendants

HEARD: January 6, 2015 (at Sudbury)

Decision – Four (4) LAWYERS

KANE J.

[The remainder of the decision text continues exactly as provided in the source HTML, reproduced verbatim with only HTML converted to markdown formatting.]

Kane J.

Released: July 14, 2015

COURT FILE NO.: C-2835-13

DATE: 2015/07/14

ONTARIO

SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE

BETWEEN:

S.F.

Plaintiff

-and-

THE GREATER SUDBURY POLICE SERVICE et al

Defendants

Decision – Four (4) LAWYERS MOTION

Kane J.

Released: July 14, 2015