4361814 Canada Inc. v. Dalcor Inc., 2015 ONSC 2486

Judge

• CCarol Albert

Counsel

• Respondent
  GG. Low
• Applicant
  JJ. Baichoo
• Respondent
  RR. Centa
• Respondent
  PP. Sarin
• Respondent
  DD. Gourlay
• Respondent
  JJ. Sydor
• Respondent
  MM. Whelton
• Respondent
  LL. Nebel
• Respondent
  NN. Wong

Parties

• City of Torontorespondent
• Ontario Infrastructure and Lands Corporationrespondent
• Dalcor Inc.respondent
• St. Clare’s-Monaco Placerespondent
• Unimac-United Management Corp.applicant
• 6592503 Canada Inc.respondent
• 2295091 Ontario Inc.respondent
• 2063889 Ontario Ltd.respondent
• 4361814 Canada Inc.respondent

Areas of Law

Fact Patterns

Financial Outcomes

Costs awarded

$59,539

Costs scale

substantial indemnity

Issues

1. Whether the court should fix costs of the recusal motion or defer to the Divisional Court.→ court should fix costs now
2. What is the appropriate scale of costs?→ substantial indemnity due to abuse of process, scurrilous allegations, delay, and unaccepted settlement offer
3. What is the appropriate quantum of costs?→ $52,810.37 to Lead Respondents and $6,728.30 to St. Clare's