City of Hamilton v. Attorney General et al., 2015 ONSC 1839
COURT FILE NO.: C-383-04
DATE: 2015-02-20
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN:
City of Hamilton
Plaintiff
Attorney General of Canada, Christine Stewart, David Anderson Herb Dhaliwal, Sheila Copps, Nancy Adams, Paul Bernier, W. Bill Bien, Edwin R. De Bruyn, Steve Burgess, Mike Cadman, Paula Caldwell, Robert Connelly, Rob Dobos, Margit Doneit, John Fischer, Rosaline Frith, Nicole Gagnier, Denise Gibbs, Cathy Gee, Jonathan H. Gee, Sid Gershberg, D. V. Gillman, Carole Giroux, Ian Glen, Michael Goffin, Francois Guimont, Len Good, Keith Grady, Barbara Hennessy, Michaela Huard, Wayne Hyatt, Louise Knox, Mary Komarynsky, Janice Kostash, Olivier Lalande, Deb Lauder, Patrice Leblanc, Sharon Leonhard, Simon Llewellyn, Nancy Maguire, Laud Matos, Claire Michaud, John Mills, Tom Muir, Brad Parker, L.S. Parsons, Raymond Pierce, Richard Pratt, Ulana Perovic, Kim Ray, David Robinson, Michael Rayner, Guy Riverin, David Robinson, Craig Ryan, Nathalie Seguin, Michael Shaw, Ron Shimizu, Mike Shiomi, Jeff Stein, Rob Stevens, Donna Stewart, John Struger, Gerry E. Swanson, Lucie Tessier, Lisa Vitpls, Wayne Wouters, Bruce Young
Defendants
Scott Smith, Ross Earnshaw, for the Plaintiff
Glynis Evans, for the Defendants
THE HONOURABLE MR. P. B. HAMBLY
Ruling on Costs on Discovery Motion
[1] The defendants were successful on the motion. The plaintiff concedes that they are entitled to their costs. They claim $9,212.36 consisting of fees of $8,732.80 and disbursements of $479.56. The defendants agree that this amount is fair and reasonable and raise no objection to it.
[2] There will be an order that the plaintiff pay costs to the defendants in the amount of $9,212.36.
P.B. Hambly, J.
Released: March 20, 2015
CITATION: City of Hamilton v. Attorney General et al., 2015 ONSC 1839
COURT FILE NO.: C-383-04
DATE: 2015-03-20
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN:
City of Hamilton
Plaintiff
Attorney General of Canada, Christine Stewart, David Anderson Herb Dhaliwal, Sheila Copps, Nancy Adams, Paul Bernier, W. Bill Bien, Edwin R. De Bruyn, Steve Burgess, Mike Cadman, Paula Caldwell, Robert Connelly, Rob Dobos, Margit Doneit, John Fischer, Rosaline Frith, Nicole Gagnier, Denise Gibbs, Cathy Gee, Jonathan H. Gee, Sid Gershberg, D. V. Gillman, Carole Giroux, Ian Glen, Michael Goffin, Francois Guimont, Len Good, Keith Grady, Barbara Hennessy, Michaela Huard, Wayne Hyatt, Louise Knox, Mary Komarynsky, Janice Kostash, Olivier Lalande, Deb Lauder, Patrice Leblanc, Sharon Leonhard, Simon Llewellyn, Nancy Maguire, Laud Matos, Claire Michaud, John Mills, Tom Muir, Brad Parker, L.S. Parsons, Raymond Pierce, Richard Pratt, Ulana Perovic, Kim Ray, David Robinson, Michael Rayner, Guy Riverin, David Robinson, Craig Ryan, Nathalie Seguin, Michael Shaw, Ron Shimizu, Mike Shiomi, Jeff Stein, Rob Stevens, Donna Stewart, John Struger, Gerry E. Swanson, Lucie Tessier, Lisa Vitpls, Wayne Wouters, Bruce Young
Defendants
costs judgment
P.B. Hambly, J.
Released: March 20, 2015