Sandra Jackson

The applicant, John Walker, sought an order under the Partition Act for the sale of a jointly owned property.

The respondents, Bethany Walker and Matthew Colling, opposed the sale, arguing it would cause them hardship amounting to oppression and requested a stay until an estate trustee was appointed and a Henson trust established.

The court found the respondents failed to demonstrate oppression, noting their inconsistent financial disclosures, the property's deteriorating condition, and the applicant's need for the sale proceeds for his care.

The court granted the order for sale, requiring the respondents to vacate and setting terms for the sale process.

The defendant was charged with two offences under the Regional Municipality of Waterloo By-Law 16-023 (as amended by By-Law 18-023): offering tow truck services within 200 metres of an accident scene and positioning a tow truck within 200 metres of an accident scene.

The defendant challenged the validity of the amended by-law as inconsistent with the Highway Traffic Act.

The court found that the amended by-law conflicted with section 177(3) of the Highway Traffic Act, which provides an exception for towing services in emergencies.

The court determined that an accident constitutes an emergency and that the by-law's complete prohibition on tow truck presence within 200 metres of an accident scene eliminated the provincial emergency exception.

The court found the amended by-law invalid and dismissed both charges.

This trial decision addresses the equalization of net family property, spousal support, and s. 7 child support expenses following a 20-year marriage.

Key disputes included the attribution of diamond rings and a joint bank account, the existence of a debt to the applicant's sister for a California property, the respondent's personal debts, and the valuation of a Honda and RRSPs at the date of marriage.

The court imputed income for both parties for support purposes and denied the respondent's request for a right of first refusal on a jointly-owned property.