The accused was tried on two counts of sexual assault involving his niece in a shared family household.
The central issue was whether the complainant's evidence, though accepted as sincere and forthright, established the charges beyond a reasonable doubt in light of reliability concerns, the physical context of the alleged incidents, uncertainty surrounding deleted app messages, and the accused's police statement and apology letter.
The court held this was not a repressed-memory case, but found the surrounding circumstances and internal inconsistencies left a reasonable doubt on both counts.
Both charges were dismissed.