Court of Appeal for Ontario
Date: 2017-10-23 Docket: C63172 Judges: MacFarland, Hourigan and Pardu JJ.A.
Between
Anjum Anjum and Musart Hayee Plaintiffs (Respondent)
and
John Doe and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company Defendants (Appellant)
Counsel
Ari Krajden, for the appellant
Ryan Breedon, for the respondent
Heard and Released
Heard and released orally: October 23, 2017
On appeal from: the judgment of Justice P.J. Cavanagh of the Superior Court of Justice, dated December 12, 2016.
Reasons for Decision
[1] The appellant challenges the motion judge's findings of credibility and reliability of Ms. Rossi, pointing to possible frailties in her evidence. The judge addressed these issues. The appellant essentially argues that the motion judge ought to have weighed the evidence differently. We see no error in the motion judge's approach. He carefully considered the evidence and made findings based on the whole of the evidence.
[2] Further, the appellant submits that the motion judge engaged in speculation rather than rational inference coming to his conclusion. We do not agree. The reasons of the motion judge are logically connected to the whole of the evidence and make rational sense.
[3] Finally, the appellant also argues that the motion judge erred in concluding that there was no contributory negligence on the part of the respondent driver. The question as framed for the motion judge was whether an unknown driver caused or contributed to the accident.
[4] This case was presented on an all or nothing basis. The appellant took the position that there was no unknown other driver. The respondent driver alleged that he was suddenly cut off by another driver sending him into the ditch. At the hearing the appellant did not take issue with this characterization of the liability issue the motion judge was asked to determine.
[5] We see no error on the part of the motion judge and the appeal is accordingly dismissed. Costs to the respondent fixed in the sum of $9,924.21 inclusive of disbursements and HST.
J. MacFarland J.A.
C.W. Hourigan J.A.
G. Pardu J.A.



