COURT OF APPEAL FOR ONTARIO
CITATION: Korea Data Systems (USA), Inc. v. Aamazing Technologies Inc. (Ajay Amazing Technologies Inc.), 2014 ONCA 863
DATE: 20141202
DOCKET: M43880, M43941, M44009, M44015 and M44059 (C55916)
Watt, Tulloch and Benotto JJ.A.
BETWEEN
Korea Data Systems (USA), Inc.
Plaintiff (Appellant)
and
Aamazing Technologies Inc. carrying on business as Ajay Amazing Technologies Inc., Jay Chiang, a.k.a. Jay Tien Chiang a.k.a. Tienchieh Chiang, Julius Chiang and Christina Chiang a.k.a. Christian Chiang a.k.a. Suh Mei Tasi, a.k.a. Suh Mei Tsai a.k.a. Christina Suh Mei Tsai, a.k.a. Suh Mei Tasi Chiang, a.k.a. Christina Suh-Mei Chiang a.k.a. Suh-Mei Chiang, and Dong Liang a.k.a. Tung Liang
Defendants (Respondents in Appeal)
AND BETWEEN:
Mendlowitz & Associates Inc. in its capacity as Trustee in bankruptcy of Jay Tien Chiang, and Korea Data Systems (USA), Inc.
Plaintiffs (Appellant)
and
Jay Tien Chiang, a.k.a. Jay Chiang, a.k.a. Tienchieh Chiang, Christina Chiang, also known as Suh Mei Tasi, a.k.a. Christian Chiang a.k.a. Suh Mei Tsai, a.k.a. Christina Suh Mei Tsai, a.k.a. Suh Mei Tasi Chiang, a.k.a. Christina Suh-Mei Chiang a.k.a. Suh-Mei Chiang, Chun Chun Wu, Jie Chu Wu, Chen Cheng-Yueh Tsai, Yu Chang Chiang also known as Y.C. Chiang, En Fu Chiang, Brenda Chang, Samson Chang, David Cheng, Everview Inc., 961266 Ontario Inc., 1204360 Ontario Inc., 1243723 Ontario Inc., Aamazing Technologies Inc., Wen Wang Chiang a.k.a. Wen Chiang a.k.a. Wen Wang, Crystalview Technology Corp., E.C. Holdings Ltd., Telepower International (Canada), Inc., Best Buy Electronics Inc., Su Feng Tsai a.k.a. Tsai Su Feng, Tsai Zheng Li, Tsai Zheng Ying, Asia Pacific Gateway (H.K.) Ltd., Century Group Holdings Ltd., Albany Investments Ltd., Mei Huang, Winner International Group Limited, Huang Chi Lung, Min Huang, Wainwright Ventures Ltd., New Global Investment Limited and Floratino Limited
Defendants (Respondents in Appeal)
Scott Hutchison, for the moving party Korea Data Systems (USA), Inc. on M44059
Hilary Book, for the moving party Christina Chiang on M43941 and M44015
Catherine Francis and Mark A. Freake, for the moving party Mendlowitz & Associates Inc. on M43880
J.T. Curry and K.M. Pentney, for moving party Jay Chiang on M44009
Heard: August 25, 2014
On motion for directions on the appeal from the order of Associate Chief Justice Frank N. Marrocco of the Superior Court of Justice, dated July 9, 2012.
COSTS ENDORSEMENT
[1] The appellant Korea Data Systems (USA) was successful on the motion heard by this Court on August 25, 2014.
[2] The issues in the motion were complex and the history was extensive.
[3] The appellant is awarded costs fixed in the amount of $25,000 - inclusive of disbursements and applicable taxes – to be paid jointly by the Trustee and Christina Chiang.
"David Watt J.A."
"M. Tulloch J.A."
"M.L. Benotto J.A."