The Ontario College of Teachers alleged that the respondent member was incompetent and guilty of professional misconduct due to significant deficiencies in classroom management, planning, and teaching strategies.
The allegations were based primarily on the evidence of a school principal who conducted performance appraisals.
The Discipline Committee found the principal's evidence to be unreliable, inconsistent with contemporaneous documents, and contradicted by video evidence of the member's teaching.
The Committee also noted the College's failure to call expert evidence to establish the standard of competence expected of teachers.
Concluding that the College failed to meet its burden of proof on a balance of probabilities, the Committee dismissed all allegations of incompetence and professional misconduct.