The applicants, a police constable and the Toronto Police Service, brought an application for certiorari to quash a trial judge's ruling issuing a subpoena to the constable to testify on a Charter application in a criminal trial.
The applicants argued that a draft statement of claim and information provided to the defence by another officer were protected by settlement privilege and unlawfully disclosed, triggering the third-party records regime.
The Superior Court dismissed the application, finding no jurisdictional error or error of law on the face of the record in the trial judge's conclusions that settlement privilege did not apply, the disclosure was not unlawful, and the test for issuing a subpoena was met.
