This decision clarifies the interpretation of "at trial" under section 25(4) of the Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA), holding that a young person is considered "at trial" from the moment they decide to contest charges, including during the pre-trial or case management phase, without requiring formal arraignment or plea.
The court emphasized the broad statutory right to counsel throughout all stages of proceedings, consistent with Parliament’s intent and international law commitments such as the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
The decision also recommends procedural reforms to allow YCJA section 25(4) applications to be submitted electronically and decided without formal hearings when uncontested, to conserve judicial resources and reduce burdens on vulnerable youth.
