Michelle D. Reynolds

Following the partial dismissal of an appeal and the remittal of a breach of contract issue for trial, the parties made written submissions on whether security should remain in place pending the trial.

The Court of Appeal held that the issue of security should be decided by the trial court.

The court ordered the security to remain in place for 60 days to allow the appellant to move for security in the trial court.

The Court of Appeal issued a costs endorsement following an appeal where the appellant lost on the primary issue of oppression but succeeded in obtaining a new trial on an unresolved breach of contract issue.

The court found that responsibility for the failure to litigate the contract issue was divided between the parties.

Given the unusual circumstances and divided success, the court concluded that a fair costs award was for each side to bear its own costs throughout the proceedings.