2 total
Costs of the appeal and proceeding below awarded to the appellants on a partial indemnity scale.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario issued a costs endorsement following an appeal.
The appellants were awarded costs on a partial indemnity scale for both the appeal and the proceeding below.
The costs were fixed at $45,000 for one group of appellants, $20,000 for another group, and $60,000 for a single appellant, inclusive of GST and disbursements.
Sponsors are owed fairness before governments enforce sponsorship debt.
Appeal from dismissal of an application challenging the enforcement of immigration sponsorship undertakings after sponsored relatives received Ontario social assistance.
The court held that the federal and provincial governments have a case-by-case discretion whether to enforce sponsorship debt, and that Ontario unlawfully fettered that discretion by applying policies inconsistent with the family class immigration scheme.
The court further held that sponsors are owed procedural fairness before enforcement, including a meaningful opportunity to explain relevant personal and financial circumstances, consideration of those submissions, and notice of the decision made.
The court rejected the argument that undertakings signed under the former immigration statute became unenforceable under the new regime.
