The Crown appealed the imposition of a 20-month conditional sentence for domestic violence offences and breach of probation.
The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge erred by underestimating the gravity of the offences and that a penitentiary sentence was clearly warranted.
However, because the respondent had already served almost 12 months of house arrest and completed a rehabilitation program, the Court declined to reincarcerate him and dismissed the appeal.