Freeman Choi

The appellant, Paccar Leasing Company Ltd., appealed a motion judge's order that Royal Bank of Canada's perfected security interest in a debtor's property prevailed over Paccar's unperfected security interest in leased commercial trucks.

Paccar argued that its "true lease" meant it retained title, giving it priority.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, affirming that the 2007 amendments to the Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) prioritize perfected security interests over common law notions of title, even for true leases, if the lessor fails to perfect their interest.

Parkdale Community Legal Services (PCLS) sought leave to intervene as a friend of the court in a motion for leave to appeal concerning an employment dispute and the enforceability of an arbitration clause under the Arbitration Act and Employment Standards Act.

The underlying appeal sought to clarify principles regarding contracting out of the ESA and the application of statutory bars to appeals.

Despite the consent of the appellant and no opposition from the respondent, the court dismissed the motion for leave to intervene, emphasizing that granting intervener status at the leave to appeal stage is a rare and extraordinary event, and PCLS had not met the high onus of establishing their contribution was necessary at this preliminary stage.