The applicants, former employees of General Motors who retired under a 1992 retirement incentive plan, alleged that their union breached its duty of fair representation.
They claimed the union misrepresented their eligibility for a more lucrative $35,000 retirement allowance negotiated in 1993 and treated them differently from other employees who were permitted to return to active duty to qualify.
The Board dismissed the application, finding no evidence that the union acted arbitrarily, discriminatorily, or in bad faith, noting that the union could not have known about the future incentive when the applicants enrolled in the earlier plan.