David Richard Mackenzie

This endorsement concerns a joint motion brought by the court-appointed Monitors for JTI-Macdonald Corp., Imperial Tobacco Canada Limited, Imperial Tobacco Company Limited, and Rothmans, Benson & Hedges Inc. in their ongoing Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) proceedings.

The Monitors sought a Sanction Protocol Order to establish the date for the Sanction Hearing, ratify the litigation timetable, approve the dissemination of the Agenda and Sanction Hearing procedure, approve the Omnibus Sanction Hearing Notice, and set the deadline for Sanction Hearing Objection Notices.

The motion was unopposed and was granted by the court, with three orders signed.

Travelers Insurance Company of Canada appealed the dismissal of part of its subrogated claim for payment from proceeds of crime forfeited to the Crown.

The core issue was whether Travelers had an interest in the forfeited property by way of a constructive trust due to the Crown's erroneous failure to include Travelers' subrogated claim (Xpertdoc) in the initial restitution order.

The Court of Appeal found that the Crown's erroneous omissions, combined with the near certainty that restitution would have been made, amounted to unjust enrichment, supporting a constructive trust in Travelers' favour.

The appeal was allowed, and Travelers was granted relief from forfeiture for the full amount of the Xpertdoc claim.