Clifford I. Cole

The plaintiff brought a motion under Rule 5.04(2) to amend the title of proceedings to correct an alleged misnomer, seeking to substitute 'Downtown Auto Collision Centre Inc.' for the named plaintiff 'Dealer’s Choice Preferred Collision Centre Inc.'.

The action alleged breach of a 2013 agreement.

The court found that the defendants had specifically rejected the inclusion of Downtown Auto as a party to the agreement during negotiations.

Applying the 'litigating finger' test, the court concluded the defendants would have had no reason to think the intended plaintiff was Downtown Auto.

The motion was dismissed with costs awarded to the defendants.

Following a successful appeal of an arbitration award, the appellants sought costs for the appeal and two preliminary motions.

The respondents argued success was divided and disputed the scale and quantum.

The court found the appellants were entirely successful and entitled to costs for the appeal and the preliminary motions, which were necessitated by the respondents' ill-advised motion to quash.

The court declined to award substantial indemnity costs, finding no reprehensible conduct, and fixed costs on a partial indemnity scale at $54,284.74.

The appellants appealed an arbitration award under s. 45 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, arguing the arbitrator exceeded his jurisdiction by directing the boards of two corporate parties to determine the profits of a non-party US corporation.

The Superior Court of Justice agreed, finding that an arbitrator cannot bind or govern the affairs of a non-party.

The appeal was allowed in part, and the specific paragraph of the formal judgment affecting the non-party was set aside and remitted to the arbitrator with directions.

Following a successful motion, the plaintiff sought costs on a substantial indemnity basis or, alternatively, on a partial indemnity basis.

The self-represented defendant did not provide costs submissions.

The court awarded costs to the plaintiff on a partial indemnity basis, fixing the amount at $2,500.00, payable within 60 days.