Brittany Ariel Sokol Davis

This is a costs decision following the respondent's successful appeal of orders certifying an action as a class proceeding and granting leave to proceed under the Securities Act.

The respondent sought $120,000 in total costs ($20,000 for the Divisional Court leave to appeal motion and $50,000 for each of two appeals to the Court of Appeal).

The court awarded $70,000 in total costs ($20,000 for the leave to appeal and $50,000 for the appeals), finding that while there were technically two separate appeals, the issues and arguments were inextricably bound together in substance.

This appeal concerns the certification of a class proceeding and the granting of leave to proceed with a secondary market misrepresentation claim under the Securities Act.

The respondent, a former shareholder of Akumin Inc., sought to certify a class action on behalf of purchasers of Akumin securities (common shares and secured notes) alleging misrepresentations in financial statements and seeking relief under both statutory provisions and common law negligence.

The appellants challenged both the leave order and the certification order, arguing that certain disclosures did not constitute "public corrections," that an efficient market requirement applied to secondary market claims, and that common law negligence claims should not be certified alongside statutory claims.

The Court of Appeal upheld the motion judge's decisions, clarifying the law on public corrections, rejecting an efficient market requirement, and confirming that common law claims can be certified alongside statutory claims.