Alexander Charles Gibson

The appellant, Liviu Calin, appealed findings of liability for assault, battery, negligence, and breach of fiduciary duty, and the quantum of damages awarded to his twin daughters, Ilinca and Ana Calin.

The respondents cross-appealed the dismissal of their claim for intentional infliction of mental distress and the quantum of damages.

The Court of Appeal dismissed both the appeal and the cross-appeal, upholding the trial judge's factual findings, credibility assessments, and damages award, and affirming the trial judge's causation analysis regarding psychiatric conditions.

Following a successful civil action for abuse against their father, Liviu Calin, plaintiffs Ana and Ilinca Calin sought costs of over $395,000.

The court, applying Rule 57.01 factors, found the requested costs disproportionately high given the significant disparity between the $10.15 million claimed and the $105,000 awarded.

While acknowledging the plaintiffs' success and the principles of the Victims' Bill of Rights, the court determined that the plaintiffs' pursuit of unrealistic claims, particularly for income loss and incidents in Romania, unnecessarily lengthened proceedings.

The court awarded the plaintiffs $100,000 in costs, reduced by a prior $17,000 order against them, resulting in a net payment of $83,000 from the defendant.

The defendants moved for summary judgment to dismiss the plaintiff's action for negligence and breach of contract, arguing the claim was statute-barred.

The plaintiff alleged negligence by real estate agents regarding a right of first refusal in a 2008 property sale.

The court applied the discoverability principle under the Limitations Act, 2002, and found that the plaintiff, a licensed real estate agent, ought to have known of her claim against the real estate agents before June 12, 2013, more than two years before commencing the action in June 2015.

Consequently, the action was dismissed as statute-barred.