The appellants, a standardbred owner/trainer and an owner/groom, appealed decisions of the Judges fining and suspending them for allegedly refusing to comply with directions, withholding information, and misleading investigators regarding the transfer of horses from a suspended trainer.
The Ontario Racing Commission allowed the appeal in part, finding that the Judges' directions were equivocal and the appellants did not knowingly withhold information.
However, the Commission upheld the finding that the appellants misled investigators by participating in a deceptive 'farming out' arrangement.
The fines and suspensions were reduced, and a related suspension of four horses was modified to allow their transfer to the appellants after a specified date.