Yoni Silberman

The defendant daycare brought a motion for summary judgment in a negligence action after a three-year-old child broke his arm falling from a play structure.

The court dismissed the motion, finding that the issues of supervision adequacy, staff training, and policy implementation required significant credibility assessments and a highly contextual legal analysis, making the case unsuitable for resolution via summary judgment.

The court emphasized the difficulty of assessing credibility on a paper record, particularly when the injured child could not provide evidence, and declined to order a mini-trial.

Following the plaintiff's success in resisting an appeal from a Master's order, the parties made written submissions on costs.

The plaintiff sought costs on a substantial indemnity scale or, alternatively, on a partial indemnity scale.

The court found no reason to award costs on an elevated scale and fixed the plaintiff's costs on a partial indemnity basis at $4,000 inclusive of disbursements and taxes.