COURT FILE NO.: FS-19-00000162-0000
DATE: 2023 11 16
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN:
Romeo Banzon Tan
Applicant
– and –
Jennifer De Leon Tan
Respondent
Romeo Tan, In Person
Elliott Braganza, Counsel for the Respondent
HEARD: January 30 and 31, 2023 and February 1 and 2, March 9, May 18, June 26, July 12, 2023
Justice G.D. Lemon
CORRIGENDUM
[1] Paragraph 170 of the Reasons for Judgment, dated September 5, 2023, is amended to read:
[170] Pursuant to the Spousal Support Guidelines, (taking into consideration their incomes as set out above and the s. 7 determination below) the range of spousal support was nil in 2021 and nil in 2022. Accordingly, spousal support shall end July 1, 2021. While Ms. Tan’s need and entitlement otherwise continues, Mr. Tan has no ability to support her.
[2] Paragraph 228 of the Reasons for Judgment, dated September 5, 2023, is amended to read:
[228] I asked the parties to review the FRO payment statement to agree upon what has been paid to date, but they could not agree. Neither appeared to take into consideration the $18,600 that Mr. Tan paid in 2022. I therefore leave the final calculations to the FRO based on the findings set out above and summarized in the chart below. If there are difficulties in that calculation, I shall remain seized of this issue.
Applicant Mr. Tan’s income
Respondent
Ms. Tan’s income:
- Employed Income
Child Support
to be paid
(/Month)
Spousal Support
to be paid
(/Month)
Section 7 expenses
(Yearly / 12) – if entitled
Proportionate Sharing % - if entitled
2015
$235,000
$ 0
$ 1892
$ 6,500
2016
$235,000
$ 3473.50
$ 1892
$ 6,500
2017
$235,000
$ 6,947
$ 1892
$ 6,500
2018
$235,000
$ 6,947
$ 1892
$ 6,500
2019
$235,000
$ 6,947
$ 0 (Sept 1, 2019)
$ 6,500
$ 4,434 (Sept 1, 2019)
65/35
2020
$235,000
$ 6947
$ 0
$ 6,500
$3,009
65/35
2021
$71,388
$ 19,630
$ 0
$ 6,500 to July 2021 and then $0
$2,635
57/43
2022
$38,397
$ 41,455
$ 0
$ 0 as of January 1
$2,799 to June 2023
48/52
[3] Paragraph 233 of the Reasons for Judgment, dated September 5, 2023, is amended to read:
[233] Mr. Tan’s obligation to pay child support ended June 1, 2023; the date of his last payment.
Justice G. D. Lemon
Released: November 16, 2023
COURT FILE NO.: FS-19-00000162-0000
DATE: 2023 11 16
ONTARIO
SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE
BETWEEN:
Romeo Banzon Tan
Applicant
– and –
Jennifer De Leon Tan
Respondent
CORRIGENDUM
Justice G.D. Lemon
Released: November 16, 2023