Sarah Macaluso

This decision addresses costs following a five-day summary trial in an estate matter concerning the authenticity of a "Questioned Document" and ownership of various assets.

The Estate Trustee was largely successful, particularly regarding the document's authenticity and several asset claims.

The court found the Respondents, primarily Alex Hayward, prolonged the proceedings by disputing the document's authenticity and other claims.

Applying principles of estate costs, the court ordered full indemnification for the Estate Trustee, with substantial indemnity costs payable by the active Respondents (Alex, Shawn, David, Lori Hayward) and the balance from the Estate.

The active Respondents also received a portion of their costs from the Estate due to partial success on some claims.

The applicant estate trustee brought a summary trial to determine the ownership of various assets, including vehicles, tractors, furniture, and sheds, following the death of the deceased.

The deceased's former husband, the respondent, claimed ownership of several items and sought reimbursement for a roof replacement and a vehicle purchase.

The court first determined that a supplementary separation agreement from 2002 was authentic, relying on expert evidence regarding thermal fax technology.

Applying this agreement and other evidence, the court allocated ownership of the disputed items between the estate, the respondent, and the children.

The court dismissed the respondent's claims for reimbursement for the roof and vehicle, finding the roof claim was statute-barred and failed the test for unjust enrichment, and the vehicle purchase was a gift.